Skip to main content
Original Research · Updated October 11, 2026 · OfflistMe source-documented guide data

Data Broker Opt-Out Difficulty Index: 100 Guide Records Reviewed

OfflistMe reviewed the source-documented opt-out records for 100 US/global broker and related provider guides and scored each on documented difficulty, timing notes, and verification notes. The result: 7% may demand an ID or supporting document, timing is provider- and route-dependent, and 20 brokers rate Hard or Very Hard, typically because of account walls, identity-verification steps, or escalation needs. The full per-broker table is below, free to reuse under CC BY 4.0.

Rahul Kandoriya
Written byRahul Kandoriya·Founder, OfflistMe·Last updated October 31, 2026

Guide records reviewed

100

May require ID

7%

Timing model

Provider-dependent

Hard / Very Hard

20

How difficult is opting out?

Distribution of the 100 source-documented guide records across the 1–5 difficulty scale. The score describes the recorded path; actual effort can differ when a provider changes its form, requests verification, or uses a different route for a particular person.

Very Easy
6 (6%)
Easy
27 (27%)
Moderate
47 (47%)
Hard
18 (18%)
Very Hard
2 (2%)

Beyond difficulty: the Opt-Out Burden Score

The 1–5 difficulty rating is one editorial input. The Opt-Out Burden Score combines it with five recorded facts about each route (an ID request, sensitive identifiers such as SSN or date of birth in the form, an email or code confirmation loop, an email-only route, and a noindex tag on the opt-out page) into a 0–100 number for all 1034 catalog brokers. The companion Exposure Reach Score counts state registry matches, sibling brands under a shared parent, and people-search publishing.

Opt-Out Burden Score by broker category

Median score across 1,034 catalog brokers is 28 of 100. 341 Light, 673 Moderate, 18 Heavy, 2 Severe.

  • Median Opt-Out Burden
  • Median Exposure Reach
Social, Marketplaces & Platforms33 burden
10 reach
Marketing & Audience Data28 burden
13 reach
Credit, Risk & Identity28 burden
13 reach
B2B & Sales Intelligence27 burden
18 reach
Advertising & Adtech26 burden
16 reach
People Search & Public Records26 burden
38 reach

Chart by OfflistMe · offlist.me

Burden weights: catalog difficulty 45, government ID 15, sensitive identifiers (SSN, date of birth, ID numbers) 10, confirmation loop 5, email-only route 10, noindex on the opt-out page 15. Categories with fewer than 20 brokers are omitted. OBS v1 (2026-10-31); ERS v1 (2026-10-31). Full method

Show the data as a table
Opt-Out Burden Score by broker category data table
CategoryBrokersMedian burdenMedian reachHeavy or Severe burden
Social, Marketplaces & Platforms6633100%
Marketing & Audience Data35228131%
Credit, Risk & Identity23528136%
B2B & Sales Intelligence14827181%
Advertising & Adtech14126160%
People Search & Public Records9226382%

Sources: OfflistMe broker directory · Removal friction benchmark (CSV) · State data broker registry crosswalk · Corporate ownership graph · Opt-out page noindex scan · Checked catalog snapshot at build

4 brokers score 50+ on both burden and reach

These companies are formally present across several registries or brand families and also run a demanding opt-out route, so they repay attention first.

  • Opt-Out Burden
  • Exposure Reach
Instant Checkmate65 burden
88 reach
Intelius65 burden
75 reach
Interactive Data, LLC70 burden
50 reach
Knowledge Works, Inc59 burden
59 reach

Chart by OfflistMe · offlist.me

Show the data as a table
4 brokers score 50+ on both burden and reach data table
BrokerCategoryBurdenReach
Instant CheckmatePeople Search & Public Records6588
InteliusPeople Search & Public Records6575
Interactive Data, LLCMarketing & Audience Data7050
Knowledge Works, IncCredit, Risk & Identity5959

Sources: OfflistMe broker directory · Removal friction benchmark (CSV) · State data broker registry crosswalk · Corporate ownership graph · Opt-out page noindex scan · Checked catalog snapshot at build

How timing is represented

The current publication layer does not turn legacy timing estimates into a cross-provider average. Check the provider's current acknowledgement or notice, retain the request evidence, and distinguish provider processing from search-index changes and later reappearance. See Why data reappears →

The 20 hardest brokers to opt out of

BrokerDifficultyTiming noteGovernment-ID statusGuide
Instant CheckmateVery Hard (5/5)Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedSteps →
The Work Number (Equifax Workforce Solutions)Very Hard (5/5)Varies by provider, request, and current routeYesSteps →
AcxiomHard (4/5)Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedSteps →
Asset International (ISS)Hard (4/5)Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedSteps →
Civil Data Research (SearchPublicRecords)Hard (4/5)Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedSteps →
CoreLogicHard (4/5)Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedSteps →
Data AxleHard (4/5)Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedSteps →
Dun & BradstreetHard (4/5)Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedSteps →
EpsilonHard (4/5)Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedSteps →
EquifaxHard (4/5)Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedSteps →
ExperianHard (4/5)Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedSteps →
Information Data Resources (PublicInfoServices)Hard (4/5)Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedSteps →
InfoTracerHard (4/5)Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedSteps →
KidsLiveSafe (Scalable Commerce)Hard (4/5)Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedSteps →
National Data Analytics (PublicDataCheck)Hard (4/5)Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedSteps →
Pacific East ResearchHard (4/5)Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedSteps →
PeopleSmartHard (4/5)Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedSteps →
PublicRecordsHard (4/5)Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedSteps →
SpokeoHard (4/5)Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedSteps →
WhitepagesHard (4/5)Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedSteps →

Full index: 100 source-documented guide records

Sorted hardest-first. Every row links to the step-by-step removal guide represented by that record. Dataset licensed CC BY 4.0 — cite “OfflistMe Data Broker Opt-Out Difficulty Index” with a link to this page.

BrokerDifficultyTiming noteIDEmail channelGuide
Instant Checkmate●●●●● 5/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
The Work Number (Equifax Workforce Solutions)●●●●● 5/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeYesYesSteps →
Acxiom●●●●○ 4/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Asset International (ISS)●●●●○ 4/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Civil Data Research (SearchPublicRecords)●●●●○ 4/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
CoreLogic●●●●○ 4/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Data Axle●●●●○ 4/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Dun & Bradstreet●●●●○ 4/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Epsilon●●●●○ 4/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Equifax●●●●○ 4/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Experian●●●●○ 4/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Information Data Resources (PublicInfoServices)●●●●○ 4/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
InfoTracer●●●●○ 4/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
KidsLiveSafe (Scalable Commerce)●●●●○ 4/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
National Data Analytics (PublicDataCheck)●●●●○ 4/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
Pacific East Research●●●●○ 4/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
PeopleSmart●●●●○ 4/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
PublicRecords●●●●○ 4/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Spokeo●●●●○ 4/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Whitepages●●●●○ 4/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Address Clearing House (ACH)●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
AnyWho●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Aristotle International●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Backgrounds Online (IQ Data Systems)●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeYesYesSteps →
BeenVerified●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Best Pick Reports●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
CheckPeople●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
CityData.AI●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Clearview AI●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
ContactOut●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
CourtRecords.us●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Crunchbase●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
CyberBackgroundChecks●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
Dealfront (Leadfeeder)●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Electronic Voice Services (TelephoneLists.biz)●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
FamilyTreeNow●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
Findem●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
FreePeopleSearch.com●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
GitHub●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeYesYesSteps →
InCheck Solutions●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Intelius●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Kochava●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
LiveRamp●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
Marriott International●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Merkle●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
MyLife●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Nielsen●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
NumberGuru●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
NumLookup●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Nuwber●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Oracle Advertising (Data Cloud)●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
People Data Labs●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeYesYesSteps →
PeopleFinders DaaS●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
PeopleWhiz●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeYesYesSteps →
PrivateRecords●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
PublicRecord.com●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeYesYesSteps →
Reply.io●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Reunion.com●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
RevContent●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
SalesIntel●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Share Local Media●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
SpyCloud●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Thomson Reuters CLEAR●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeYesYesSteps →
TruthFinder●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
US Search●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
USPeopleSearch●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
ZS Associates●●●○○ 3/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
AddressSearch●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
Clearbit●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Cognism●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Datanyze●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
FastPeopleSearch●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
FreePeopleDirectory●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
Innovis●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
Kaspr●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
LeadIQ●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Lusha●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
NeighborWho●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Ownerly●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
PeopleFinder●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
PeopleFinders●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
PeopleLooker●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
PeopleSearchNow●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
Quora●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
RecordsFinder●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
RocketReach●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Seamless.ai●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
StateRecords.org●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
That'sThem●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
TransUnion●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Unmask●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
UpLead●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
USA-People-Search●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
VeriPages●●○○○ 2/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedYesSteps →
Centeda●○○○○ 1/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
FindPeopleSearch●○○○○ 1/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
InstantPeopleFinder●○○○○ 1/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
PeekYou●○○○○ 1/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
Radaris●○○○○ 1/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →
TelephoneDirectories.us●○○○○ 1/5Varies by provider, request, and current routeNo routine requirement recordedNoSteps →

Macro Catalog Evidence Snapshot (1,043 Data Brokers)

Expanding beyond the source-documented step-by-step guides, OfflistMe records removal-friction and submission-pathway observations for 1,043 data brokers in the research universe using a Three-State (YES / NO / UNKNOWN) evidence model:

Direct Email Support

974 (93.4%)

Source-backed email/mailto: pathway recorded

Web Form Portals

792 (75.9%)

Dedicated online opt-out forms

ID Document Barrier

561 (99.6%)

563 observed; 480 holding UNKNOWN state

Catalog Avg Difficulty

3 / 5.0

Evidence Completeness: 54.5%

Methodological Transparency & True Denominators:

Evaluated across 563 platforms with a recorded positive or negative identity-document disclosure. 480 catalog platforms hold UNKNOWN status pending first-party submission audits. A positive state can be conditional and is not a universal mandate. OfflistMe strictly distinguishes between confirmed negative observations and unverified information—missing attributes are never treated as negative evidence. A route observation does not prove request acceptance, processing, or removal.

Methodology

Each broker in this index has a dedicated removal guide maintained by OfflistMe. To build a guide, we review the broker’s documented opt-out flow and record: the number of steps, whether account creation or identity verification is requested, CAPTCHA and email-verification friction, request method, and a timing note where a current source supports one. The published layer does not turn legacy estimates into a cross-provider average.

The difficulty score is ordinal, 1 (Very Easy: single form, no verification beyond email) to 5 (Very Hard: account walls, identity-verification steps, mail-in requests, or flows that require follow-up or escalation). Timing notes are provider- and route-dependent; they are not measured service-level benchmarks and do not guarantee that a profile will disappear. Entries are reviewed again when guides are updated; this page recomputes automatically from the underlying dataset on every build.

Limitations: difficulty is scored for a US resident using the broker’s standard consumer flow. Provider instructions, verification, disputes, legal scope, and search-index changes can all alter the practical timeline.

Frequently asked questions

Which broker or provider guides record the most opt-out friction?

Of the 100 source-documented guide records, 20 rate Hard or Very Hard (4–5 on our 5-point scale): Instant Checkmate, The Work Number (Equifax Workforce Solutions), Acxiom, Asset International (ISS), Civil Data Research (SearchPublicRecords), CoreLogic, and others. The recorded friction can include account creation, identity-verification requests, mail-only routes, or escalation steps; the reason varies by broker.

How long does removal from a data broker or related provider take?

There is no reliable cross-provider average in this index. The published guide records use provider- and route-dependent timing notes; check the current provider instructions and any applicable legal response period for the request you are making.

How many guide records mention an ID or supporting document?

7 of the 100 source-documented guide records (7%) may request a government ID or supporting document before processing a removal request. If a current route asks for a document, disclose only what is necessary and check the applicable privacy notice and law before sending it.

How is the difficulty score calculated?

Each broker is scored 1 (Very Easy) to 5 (Very Hard) from the reviewed opt-out flow and guide record: number of steps, account or identity-verification demands, CAPTCHA and email-verification friction, request method, and documented escalation needs. The score is an OfflistMe editorial observation, not a regulator finding or independent effectiveness rate.

Can I use this dataset in my own article or research?

Yes. The table is downloadable as CSV and licensed CC BY 4.0 — cite "OfflistMe Data Broker Opt-Out Difficulty Index" with a link to this page.

Generate requests in under 60 seconds

Generate requests for the hard-to-review workflows

The 20 highest-friction guide records can require more review or follow-up. OfflistMe provides request preparation for 1,034 data brokers — one-time plan options, user-controlled sending, and no provider-managed monitoring claim.