Incogni vs DeleteMe vs Optery: Source-Checked Scope and Trade-offs (2026)
Source-checked comparison of Incogni, DeleteMe, and Optery across scope, workflow, evidence, pricing, privacy, monitoring, and renewal trade-offs. No universal outcome ranking.

Incogni, DeleteMe, and Optery use different service models. A fair comparison needs to separate provider-published scope, plan price, request handling, monitoring, reports, verification, and the information a customer must share. No headline site count proves that a particular record will be removed.
This is a dated editorial comparison, not an independent outcome study. Prices, source lists, eligibility, and plan features can change. Check the linked first-party pages before purchasing.
Provider snapshot
- Incogni: Its pricing page describes tier-specific automated and custom-removal workflows with recurring plan pricing. Check the current page for live scope and terms.
- DeleteMe: Its coverage, plan, and member-help pages describe a provider-managed process and privacy reports. Check the live coverage page for the current scope.
- Optery: Its pricing page describes a free tier and paid tiers with different source scopes and features. Check the current page for live counts and limits.
- OfflistMe: The catalog contains 1,034 US/global data brokers within a 1,052-record research catalog. That is catalog and workflow scope, not a removal-outcome guarantee.
The useful question is not “which service wins?” It is which workflow matches your need for automation, control, evidence, monitoring, privacy, and recurring cost.
Comparison framework
| Dimension | What to compare | What it does not establish |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Current plan, renewal, taxes, cancellation, and limits | That a lower price produces a better result |
| Scope | Named sources, country, plan tier, and request type | That your record exists at each source |
| Handling | Whether a provider sends requests or helps you prepare them | That a request was accepted or deletion completed |
| Monitoring | Scan cadence, re-submission, reports, and plan end | That every new listing is detected |
| Evidence | Source URL, timestamp, request copy, response, and re-check | That an internal status label equals source deletion |
| Privacy | Data collected, retention, authorization, and third-party sharing | That any service has zero exposure risk |
Incogni
Incogni’s pricing page describes plan-specific automated sources and custom removals. Because those figures use different tiers and request definitions, they should not be added together or treated as a single universal coverage number. Review the live price, country eligibility, authorization, source scope, monitoring, and renewal terms before subscribing.
Tired of dealing with data exposure?
Choose relevant provider workflows, review the generated drafts in your browser, and send or submit each request yourself. Matching, eligibility, and provider requirements still need checking.
Source: Incogni pricing.
Before subscribing, check country eligibility, authorization, the identifiers you must provide, source categories, monitoring cadence, renewal, cancellation, and what evidence appears in reports. A provider-published source count is not an independently measured removal rate.
DeleteMe
DeleteMe’s official coverage help page publishes a site count that can change. Its plans page and member-help documentation describe a managed service and privacy reports. The coverage figure is provider-published scope; it does not show how many of those sources match one person, which request route each source uses, or whether a listing remains absent after a later re-check.
Sources: DeleteMe coverage help, DeleteMe plans, and member opt-out documentation.
Check the selected plan’s current price, family or individual scope, information requirements, reports, renewal, and escalation process. Do not infer an outcome from a headline coverage figure. For a wider comparison of DeleteMe alternatives and their current plan terms, see DeleteMe alternatives in 2026.
Optery
Optery’s pricing page describes a free tier and paid tiers with different source scopes. Those are tier-specific provider figures; they do not prove that every source uses the same request method or that every person has a matching profile. Review the live price, source list, limits, and request definitions before subscribing.
Source: Optery pricing.
If visual reports or screenshots are important to you, confirm exactly what the current tier shows, how often it scans, what it re-submits, and what happens after cancellation. Keep the source URL and date for any evidence you rely on.
Side-by-side snapshot
| Service | Current source snapshot | Model to investigate | Important unknowns to verify |
|---|---|---|---|
| Incogni | Tier-specific automated and custom-removal categories on the current pricing page | Provider-managed recurring requests | Matching rules, country eligibility, reports, and renewal |
| DeleteMe | Provider-published site count on the current coverage page | Provider-managed requests and reports | Source-by-source method, plan limits, and re-check behavior |
| Optery | Different source scopes by tier on the current pricing page | Tiered scanning and removal features | Exact source list, evidence format, cadence, and plan-end behavior |
| OfflistMe | 1,034 data brokers; 1,052 research records | Browser-local request preparation and user-controlled sending | User-specific matches, broker response, verification, and follow-up |
This table intentionally leaves outcome fields open. A source-backed comparison is more useful when it records what is known and what still needs checking.
Incogni vs DeleteMe vs Optery: verified plan facts
Checked October 23, 2026 on each provider's own pages in a real browser, with a second source for every price. Provider statements are not measured results.
| Fact | Incogni | DeleteMe | Optery |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cheapest paid plan (1 person, per year) | $95.88 (Standard) | $129 (Standard, 1 person) | $39 (Core) |
| Most complete plan (1 person, per year) | $179.88 (Unlimited) | Single plan | $249 (Ultimate) |
| Month-to-month option | $15.98/mo Standard | Not shown | $3.99/mo Core; $14.99/mo Extended; $24.99/mo Ultimate |
| Provider-stated coverage | 420 data broker sites (Unlimited adds custom requests to 3,000+ more sites) | 969 data brokers on the published coverage list | 380–625 sites with Expanded Reach enabled (Ultimate custom requests reach 940+) |
| Re-scan / re-request cadence | Re-sends requests every 60 days (public databases) and 90 days (private) | Every 3 months (quarterly Privacy Reports) | Monthly scans and re-submissions on paid plans |
| Free option | Free exposure scan, no account needed | Free scan; removal requires a paid plan | Free Basic tier (monitoring + self-service guides) |
| Custom removal requests | Unlimited and higher plans only | Yes (between quarterly reports) | Ultimate (unlimited, after 30 days) |
| Where it is offered | U.S., Canada, UK, EU/EEA countries and Switzerland | Plans page: U.S. residents only (a help article lists other countries) | Not confirmed |
| Trustpilot | 4.3 from 3,063 reviews (company pays for a Trustpilot subscription) | 3.6 from 263 reviews | 4 from 234 reviews (company pays for a Trustpilot subscription) |
- Incogni: The pricing page shows a struck-through "$191.76" beside the $95.88 annual charge; the chart uses the amount billed. Family $191.88/yr, Family Unlimited $275.88/yr. The page code names live pricing experiments, so displayed prices can vary by visitor.
- DeleteMe: 2 people $229/yr, family of 4 $329/yr; 2-year terms $209 (1 person). No month-to-month plan is shown.
- Optery: Core allows one name only. A Free Basic tier monitors and gives self-service removal guides.
Annual price vs OfflistMe's one-time access
Each competitor line runs from its cheapest paid individual tier to its most expensive. OfflistMe is shown as one-time 24-hour, 3-month, and 1-year access; competitor prices are amounts billed for a year.
- Services compared on this page
- OfflistMe (one-time, self-serve)
- Other services
$9 24-hour access
$36 3-month access
$60 1-year access
$19.99 Personal Plan
$39 Core
$149 Extended
$249 Ultimate
$49.99 Core
$179.99 Premium
$299.99 Ultimate
$95.88 Standard
$179.88 Unlimited
$96 Essentials
$197 Pro
$799 Signature
$99.96 Individual
$191.40 Individual Pro
$119.88 Pro
$129 Standard, 1 person
$144 Individual
$250 Core
$500 Advanced
Chart by OfflistMe · offlist.me
Show the data as a table
| Service | Tier | Billed per year | Month-to-month |
|---|---|---|---|
| DeleteMe | Standard, 1 person | $129 | Not offered |
| Incogni | Standard | $95.88 | $15.98/mo |
| Incogni | Unlimited | $179.88 | Not offered |
| OneRep | Individual | $99.96 | $14.95/mo |
| OneRep | Individual Pro | $191.40 | $29.95/mo |
| Optery | Core | $39 | $3.99/mo |
| Optery | Extended | $149 | $14.99/mo |
| Optery | Ultimate | $249 | $24.99/mo |
| Aura | Individual | $144 | $15/mo |
| Kanary | Core | $250 | $25/mo |
| Kanary | Advanced | $500 | $50/mo |
| EasyOptOuts | Personal Plan | $19.99 | Not offered |
| Privacy Bee | Essentials | $96 | Not offered |
| Privacy Bee | Pro | $197 | Not offered |
| Privacy Bee | Signature | $799 | Not offered |
| mePrism | Core | $49.99 | Not offered |
| mePrism | Premium | $179.99 | Not offered |
| mePrism | Ultimate | $299.99 | Not offered |
| GhostMyData | Pro | $119.88 | $11.99/mo |
| OfflistMe | 24-hour access | $9 one-time | Not a subscription |
| OfflistMe | 3-month access | $36 one-time | Not a subscription |
| OfflistMe | 1-year access | $60 one-time | Not a subscription |
Sources (10)
DeleteMe · Incogni · OneRep · Optery · Aura · Kanary · EasyOptOuts · Privacy Bee · mePrism · GhostMyData
Checked October 23, 2026
Which model fits which need?
A managed subscription
A managed service may fit someone who wants a provider to submit requests, perform recurring scans or re-submissions where included, and present status through provider reports. Compare the authorization and data-retention terms as carefully as the price.
A user-controlled workflow
A user-controlled workflow may fit someone who wants to review each destination and send requests from their own email account. OfflistMe prepares request guidance and drafts for the data-broker catalog; the user chooses, reviews, sends, and keeps the request and response evidence. It is not a provider-managed monitoring service.
A hybrid process
Some people may use a provider’s scan or report as one source of discovery and then independently verify selected destinations. That can be useful, but do not treat one provider’s report as a complete inventory. Record the exact source, date, match details, request status, and re-check result.
Independent test: share of people-search profiles removed after four months
Consumer Reports signed 32 volunteers up for seven paid services or manual opt-outs and re-checked 13 people-search sites (May–September 2023). Bars show the four-month result; the tick marks the one-week result.
- Manual opt-outs (study control)
- Optery (Ultimate), DeleteMe
- Other paid services
70% after 1 week · 70% after 1 month · 70% after 4 months
Researchers used each site's own opt-out process.
52% after 1 week · 58% after 1 month · 68% after 4 months
Annual cost in July 2024: $249
59% after 1 week · 61% after 1 month · 65% after 4 months
Annual cost in July 2024: $19.99
38% after 1 week · 38% after 1 month · 40% after 4 months
Annual cost in July 2024: $139.92
16% after 1 week · 26% after 1 month · 34% after 4 months
Annual cost in July 2024: $179.88
13% after 1 week · 20% after 1 month · 27% after 4 months
Annual cost in July 2024: $129
2% after 1 week · 4% after 1 month · 6% after 4 months
Annual cost in July 2024: $99
0% after 1 week · 2% after 1 month · 4% after 4 months
Annual cost in July 2024: $120
Chart by OfflistMe · offlist.me
- Small, non-random sample: four participants per service; the authors do not consider the results statistically significant.
- Services received only name, current address, and date of birth, and participants did not answer follow-up prompts or upload IDs.
- Profiles were checked on the page where they were first found; reappearance was not tested.
- Prices and products have changed since 2023-24; Incogni and OneRep were not tested.
OfflistMe was not tested either. It helps you send the same kind of direct requests the manual group sent, but this study does not measure OfflistMe.
Show the data as a table
| Service | Annual cost (July 2024) | Removed in 1 week | In 1 month | In 4 months |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Manual opt-outs (control) | $0 | 70% | 70% | 70% |
| Optery (Ultimate) | $249 | 52% | 58% | 68% |
| EasyOptOuts | $19.99 | 59% | 61% | 65% |
| IDX (Privacy tier) | $139.92 | 38% | 38% | 40% |
| Kanary | $179.88 | 16% | 26% | 34% |
| DeleteMe | $129 | 13% | 20% | 27% |
| ReputationDefender (Privacy Pro) | $99 | 2% | 4% | 6% |
| Confidently | $120 | 0% | 2% | 4% |
Sources: Consumer Reports report (PDF, Table 2) · Consumer Reports article · Checked October 23, 2026 against the published PDF
Peer-reviewed test of four removal services (2025)
71 participants subscribed to Optery, Kanary, Mozilla Monitor, or Incogni for one month and shared their dashboards with researchers.
- of found records removed on average after a one-month subscription (Optery, Kanary, Mozilla Monitor, Incogni)
- 48.2%
- highest (Incogni) and lowest (Kanary) average removal rate among the four
- 76.6% / 23.4%
- of the records the services retrieved were confirmed by participants as theirs
- 41.1%
- average overlap between 10 services' broker lists (Jaccard; 1 = identical); only 10 brokers appear on every list
- 0.21
"Removed" counts records the service marked removed or not found; it is not independently verified deletion. Only 41.1% of records the services retrieved were confirmed by participants as theirs. Source: Measuring the Accuracy and Effectiveness of PII Removal Services, Proceedings on Privacy Enhancing Technologies 2025(4).
Five-year cost if today's prices hold: renewal versus a one-time pass
Cumulative totals use each service's cheapest verified individual annual tier. OfflistMe shows both a single pass and buying one 1-year pass each year.
- Focused services
- OfflistMe
Chart by OfflistMe · offlist.me
Show the data as a table
| Service | Year 0 | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Incogni | $0 | $95.88 | $191.76 | $287.64 | $383.52 | $479.40 |
| DeleteMe | $0 | $129 | $258 | $387 | $516 | $645 |
| Optery | $0 | $39 | $78 | $117 | $156 | $195 |
| OfflistMe: pass every year | $0 | $60 | $120 | $180 | $240 | $300 |
| OfflistMe: single pass | $0 | $60 | $60 | $60 | $60 | $60 |
Sources: Incogni · DeleteMe · Optery · Checked October 23, 2026
Trustpilot ratings among services with at least 50 reviews
- Services compared on this page
- Other services
Chart by OfflistMe · offlist.me
Show the data as a table
| Service | Rating | Reviews | Trustpilot subscription |
|---|---|---|---|
| OneRep | 4.7 | 565 | Paid |
| EasyOptOuts | 4.6 | 94 | Not shown |
| Incogni | 4.3 | 3,063 | Paid |
| Aura | 4.3 | 1,342 | Paid |
| Optery | 4.0 | 234 | Paid |
| DeleteMe | 3.6 | 263 | Not shown |
Sources: OneRep Trustpilot profile · EasyOptOuts Trustpilot profile · Incogni Trustpilot profile · Aura Trustpilot profile · Optery Trustpilot profile · DeleteMe Trustpilot profile · Checked October 23, 2026
Verification checklist before choosing
- Open the current first-party pricing and coverage pages.
- Confirm whether the displayed count is a source count, an automated count, a custom-request allowance, or a tier-specific list.
- Read what personal information and authorization the service requires.
- Check whether the service sends requests, drafts them for you, or combines both approaches.
- Ask what evidence you receive: request copies, source URLs, timestamps, responses, screenshots, or only an internal status.
- Confirm re-submission cadence, monitoring after cancellation, renewal terms, and supported countries.
- Independently re-check important sources after a reasonable provider-stated or source-specific processing period.
Frequently asked questions
Is Incogni better than DeleteMe or Optery?
There is no universal answer from the cited source pages. Incogni emphasizes tiered automated and custom source categories, DeleteMe describes a managed workflow and reports, and Optery publishes tier-specific source scopes. Choose based on the workflow, evidence, privacy terms, and source list that fit your situation.
Which service covers the most sources?
The figures are not directly comparable because providers use different definitions, tiers, and request categories. Compare the named source list and request method, not just the largest number displayed on a pricing or coverage page.
Does a provider-published count prove removal?
No. It describes claimed or documented scope. Removal evidence requires a source-specific record such as the listing URL, request date, request route, broker response, and a later re-check. Even then, a later reappearance or a separate copy may require another request.
Where does OfflistMe fit?
OfflistMe is a user-controlled workflow. Its current catalog contains 1,034 data brokers and a separate 1,052-record research universe with explicit evidence states and missing fields. The catalog should not be represented as 1,052 fully verified profiles. Start at OfflistMe to review the current workflow.
Sources
Reviewed October 10, 2026. The provider pages below support only the provider-stated scope, plan, workflow, report, monitoring, or renewal descriptions used in this comparison. Prices, source lists, country eligibility, request definitions, and product terms can change. This article is not a controlled outcome study, and no provider request or account action was performed.
- Incogni pricing
- DeleteMe coverage help
- DeleteMe privacy protection plans
- DeleteMe member opt-out documentation
- Optery pricing
- FTC: what to know about people-search sites
- OfflistMe Privacy Policy
Related guides
Understand your privacy rights
Where a privacy right is relevant, these plain-English explainers show what each law covers and what to verify before making a request.
Continue with related privacy resources
Follow the route that matches your next question. Each link stays within a documented topic cluster and points to a canonical content page.
Take back your privacy today
Review provider-specific routes, prepare your requests locally, and send or submit each one yourself.
Review Provider RoutesFree to review provider routes · Optional one-time unlock from $9.00 · No subscription